Printable View
Theories will fly fast and far, but has anyone actually measured it? I doubt we will know until we see some good measurements.
Has anyone ever seen one? I may be able to get someone to actually measure this with the right equipment. No idea if we'd actually find anything, tho.
Measured what, the total capacitance when combining caps? Of course, that happens at every stage of the XO build. If you're asking about the speed of electrons then I am guessing we're having a little Sunday fun are we?
Hey I just read your article about judging the PE speaker contest over at that "other" site. That was nicely written and in the true Pano style. Now I wish I had grabbed me a plane ticket.
I doubt it since this is 2010 and we don't have any real data that tells me there is no real way to get it.Or we would have some facts on the issue.Quote:
Originally Posted by Panomaniac
I think it makes sense though so i would like to keep cap values as close as possible.Do we have any reasons to keep the values far. If so what ??? ;)
Then at the end of the day what do we have personal preferences,preferences,preferences !!! Who's right, I say do what works for you !!
I have a pair of 19 X-overs will values far apart and they sound like crap,soon to be redone with close values this is a spare pair i have was trying different caps Sonicaps and Daytons.Maybe the lamp cord had something to do with it. ;) :D
The methods of "getting it" certainly exist*. Problem is, the only market for that particular info is retrofit/DIY, as manufacturers don't need to parallel caps to get the value they seek. They either design around available values or spec a bulk order for the value they need.Quote:
Originally Posted by Altec Best
*If there's any doubt about the ability of a cap mfr to measure and quantify everything you ever wondered about and then some, read a few of the tech papers from just one such mfr;
Technical Papers
It won't be the values that sound like crap, that makes no difference.Quote:
Originally Posted by Altec Best
That is something that can make a difference.Quote:
Originally Posted by Altec Best
Funny guy.Quote:
Originally Posted by Altec Best
No electron speed Cal. Some folks think that there may be phase issues and who knows what else. I've seen no proof or even math backing that up, so I really don't know. I did put in a request for some tests with a buddy who has a very fancy LCR bridge.
I just use the big cap + small cap because it allows me to fine tune. Start with a lower value than needed an then add until you get what works best. I rarely know exactly what value is needed before hand.
Thanks for the kind words on the article. It was a fun trip. A lot of very good building going on.
Midwest Audio Fest - diyAudio
Would be very interested in your impressions of the different caps John, as I'm thinking of doing this myself. I was actually thinking of Sonicaps or Jantzen Superior Cross Caps.Quote:
Originally Posted by Altec Best
Agreed,also I think the MFG are more interested in custom orders for caps too.They charge quite a bit for custom values.Good point Brad ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by bfish
Hey Cal I was Just Kidding !! I figured you would see the lamp cord on the X-overs so I just put that in there.:p No Harm !! To be honest I have to really run down the problem because those X-overs are really bad something is obviously wrong can't be just the caps.When I get to the bottom of it will advise.Quote:
Originally Posted by Cal Weldon
Pano was a very cool article Top-Notch :2thumbsup:Quote:
Originally Posted by Panomaniac
I really don't know one way or the other on the difference in values keeping them close or far. I guess no one has ever really measured to find out one way or the other.But I think this is great talking about it and as Pano has posted he asked a buddy to measure "Good Deal" now maybe we can get some answers.
This is just how it was explained to me from Dave.And Dave does really nice work.
No problem my friend, I was laughing when I read the lampcord part. I guess I should have put a big smiley in there. That's the problem with typing, you can't see the expression. I really did mean "funny guy"Quote:
Originally Posted by Altec Best
Answers would be great. I am still stuck on the multiple capacitors altering the phase part but since I am anything but a genius, I will have my ears wide open for this one.Quote:
Originally Posted by Altec Best
[quote]
Cool Thanks Cal !!Quote:
Originally Posted by Cal Weldon
Me Too, I'm in the same boat my friend, yes indeedy :2thumbsup:Quote:
Answers would be great. I am still stuck on the multiple capacitors altering the phase part but since I am anything but a genius, I will have my ears wide open for this one.[